e.l.f.Eyeliner Pen with FeltTip Applicator, Black, 0.05 Fl Oz

Very impressed esp bc other felt tip eyeliners are more than double the price! I’m constantly impressed by elf products!

Nice and simple and comes off easy

I love the applicator style and the fine point tip but the pigment does not show up well at all and it certainly is not waterproof. I use it for details and use another thick pigmented liner for the rest.

I struggle with the brush applicators but this was awesome. Each eye was even for once, with a little help from a Bobby pin. Wish it came in more colors. It lasts very well, easy to use, doesn't smudge, it's smooth and the color is deep.

It was delivered on time and I was amazed how affordable it is. The pen fits right into your hand making it easy to apply and the velvet tip applicator helps with a percise line & wing. I have several big issues with this liner. The tip dries up so quick so I'm always having to go over my line and because it smudges & dries fast it's hard to fix without doing the whole eye over again. The other thing is that it doesn't last long. I put my makeup on in the morning and by noon it's smudged so bad I have racoon eyes. I personally find that this product has both good & bad sides but in my opinion the bad outweigh's the good. I will keep it as a backup though.

Good. Been getting these for years

Do not buy if you want dark black. First use came out gray. I thought it may need some more uses for the felt tip to saturate but it still came out gray and feels like the liner was dried out. Not a smooth gliding apply.

nice color. I have been using it for about a month and it hasn’t dried out and can easily be layered up. The tip of the pen does not write well under the eyes so I have to use the side of the pen but other than that it is great. It doesn’t really smudge. It glides smooth for the most part. The pen tip is very sturdy yet it can be manipulated to the direction or thickness of the wing or line.